"We independently review the products we recommend! When you buy through links on AHealthyBowl.com, We may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more"
Tested & Approved: The NutriChef Baking Pan Set is our most favorite thanks to its superior quality and ease of use and cleaning. In terms of design as well as durability, this baking sheet set performed excellently in all of the baking tests.
Thinking of the delicate macarons that have the power of sending your taste buds into ecstasy? And, if you are trying your luck at baking these appetizing Gold Macarons, Vanilla Macarons and Salted Caramel Macarons at home, you will need the best baking pan for macarons at your service. Here is a list of the best baking pans for macarons. Some people prefer using regular silicone baking mats for macarons to avoid the struggle of finding the best-one.
What to look for when buying a Macaron Pan?
A perfect Macaron baking sheet must have the following features:
- Must be Oven-safe, Dishwasher-safe, and non-toxic (PFOA free)
- Ease of handling through oversized edges.
- Durable & Rust-free build. The sheets should not warp at up to 450 degrees F.
- As for the dimensions, at least 12 macarons should fit easily.
Watch This Video: How to Make Fool-Proof Macarons
6 Best Baking Sheets for Macarons: Top Picks
- NutriChef Baking Pan Set (Best overall)
Read Review – Buy at Amazon - Wilton Premium Baking Sheet: (Best easy to use pan)
Read Review – Buy at Amazon - Fox Run Mini Macaron Pan (Best for Mini Macarons)
Read Review – Buy at Amazon - Good Cook Baking Sheet: (Best budget baking pan)
Read Review – Buy at Amazon - Amazqi Baking Sheet Set (Best quality)
Read Review – Buy at Amazon - Nordic Natural Aluminum Sheet (Best looking)
Read Review – Buy at Amazon
1) NutriChef NCZK3B Baking Pans 3 Piece Set
Features & Specs:
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
This NutriChef Set comes with three carbon steel baking sheets – the large one can bake over 24 cookies. This baking sheet is quite durable, and resistant to warping, breaking, or even scratching, thanks to its heavy-duty gauge steel. We tested it in the oven for up to 450°F and it performed excellently. That’s the reason, we’ve also ranked this pan as the best madeleine pan.
With this cookie sheet, you can make a batch of Macarons and homemade desserts. Other than macarons, I used it for making margarita cupcakes, chocolate fudge cookies, pumpkin brownies, pot pie muffins, and birthday cupcakes. As for the coating, the carbon steel layer is packed between nonstick layer to prevent the coating from leaking out into the ingredients. You can also check out NutriChef’s best lasagna baking pans.
Cleaning this sheet is breeze as the baking sheets are dishwasher safe; however, handwash is recommended. I’ve used these baking sheets as serving tray for kitchen ovens, toaster ovens, and countertop convection ovens. Overall, NutriChef’s baking pan set is versatile for various tasks. Its carbon steel ensures even heating while the nonstick coating makes cleanup a breeze.
You can also buy it at Walmart – WayFair
Related: Best Cast Iron Grill Pans in 2023.
2) Wilton Premium Cookie Baking Sheets Set
Features & Specs:
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
This Wilton baking sheet is among the best baking sheets for macarons thanks to its ease of use and premium nonstick coating. If you bake a lot of macarons, chocolate ginger molasses cookies, or any other Mexican appetizer, this baking sheet is for you.
Made of alloy steel with a charcoal color, and weighing around 3.67 lbs, this design is quite minimalistic. While baking chocolate fudge cookies, I didn’t face a problem of cookies sticking to the side or bottom. The nonstick coating allowed the food to be easily removed from the sheet without any remains. Besides, it was quite easy for me to use this sheet in oven due to the big handles making them ideal for baking vegetables, cooking fish sticks, and much more.
As for the drawbacks, I noticed that these sheets bend a little due to their thin build. The bending issue was common when placing them in a hot oven. However, they returned to the flattened position when cooled down. Another downside was water seeping into the edges of the sheets while washing which can eventually cause rusting.
Overall, the Wilton’s Premium Cookie Baking Sheets Set is a cookie lover’s dream. It includes three different-sized sheets for cookies of all kinds. With their premium surface, and larger handles for a better grip you’ll get an excellent baking experience.
You can also buy it at Walmart – Meijer
Related: Best pans for cinnamon rolls
3) Fox Run Mini Macaron Pan
Features & Specs:
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
If you want to bake a large batch of macarons or pastries, Fox Run’s Macaron Pan is just the right option for you. Compared to the Wilton Premium Muffin Baking Sheet, this one measures 12 x 10 inches to hold 30 macarons at a time.
This pan is sufficient for my family. The molded surface bakes the puffs, pastries, or macarons in the perfect shape. This one is the best budget pan for basic household baking. Constructed out of Carbon steel, the structure is durable without forming dents over time.
While testing this pan, I noticed that the heat distribution of this pan was much better than other pans, and the macarons were baked evenly and none of them was left unbaked. The nonstick coating also makes it easy to clean the pan with mild soap, as no residue remains.
However, since this pan doesn’t have handles on the side, I nearly bruised my hands while handling it. You’ll have to be more carefull and use some thick Oven Mitts to deal with this pan. Secondly, it is not dishwasher safe, so handwash is recommended for this pan.
Another thing that I experienced during the first two to three uses was that the pan has a thin base, and some macarons get burned. However, I tried turning the temperature down and baking them carefully to prevent any burning disaster. A little bit of practice and dealing with these drawbacks allowed me to bake a larger batch of perfect macarons with minimum cleaning.
You can also buy it at Walmart – Blanton Cladwell
Related: Best mini loaf pans
4) Nordic Ware Baker’s Half Sheet Pack
Features & Specs:
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
Nordic Ware Baker’s Half Sheet Pack includes two aluminum sheets perfect for baking cookies and other recipes. These sheets are sturdy and provide even baking thanks to their lightweight aluminum build, you’ll get a clean simplistic silver appearance. Compared to the stainless-steel baking sheets, we observed that this aluminum sheet conducts heat faster without rusting. You can also use parchment paper or Silpat on top of these aluminum baking sheets for flat and round macaron.
However, you’ll have to struggle handling these baking sheets as the edges are not panned out and there is no space to hold them. Be careful of using it for recipes with acidic ingredients like vinegar and tomato, as the aluminum is highly reactive to acidic ingredients and these baking sheets will become dark due to corrosion.
You can also buy it at Target
5) Amazqi Cookie Sheet Set
Features & Specs:
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
If you want to give the professional touch to your Macarons, you need Amazqi’s baking sheet set. Thanks to the durable carbon steel build, these baking sheets deliver equal heat distribution, and the premium Xynflon nonstick coating allows them to hold heavy food items like Macarons, chicken, ribs, and even turkey. Their moderately sized handles and smooth rolled-rim edges allow easy handling and safety of hands.
The cleaning process is super easy; even if you are making sweet desserts, there will be no sticky remains. Thanks to its 0.6 mm thickness (double than other sheets we tested), you can use this sheet to bake at up to 450°F. During our tests, we observed no warping or bending. Unlike other baking pans, I found no weird odor emitted from these sheets after a continuous use.
Though these are also dishwasher safe, I recommend handwash using a soft cleaning rug. Besides, use neutral cleaning detergent and properly dry the baking sheets before storing them to prevent bad odor. This cookie sheet set is a versatile choice, offering two different-sized sheets for different baking recipes, not just cookies.
You can also buy it at Sears
Related: Best Baguette Pans
6) Good Cook Bakeware Baking Sheet
Features & Specs:
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
Good Cook Baking Sheet is made of Alloy Stainless Steel. With a simplistic design and weight of only 1 Pound, this is a lightweight and easy to use macaron sheet. Apart from testing its durability, I tried washing it in dishwasher with metal spatulas to test its stainless steel, and this budget baking sheet turned out to be quite sturdy option with no signs of damage to nonstick surface.
However, the Good Cook Baking Sheet is prone to warping at a temperature higher than 400°F. After a few minutes of placing it in the oven, I heard a loud pop sound. This baking sheet bends out of shape which even sometimes causes it to slightly slide out of its initial position.
The baking sheet movement may not be that big problem with Macaron, but with liquid ingredients you will need the NutriChef NCZK3B baking sheet. Overall, Good Cook’s Bakeware Baking Sheet is a budget-friendly option for cookie lovers. While it’s not as versatile as the Amazqi set, it gets the job done. It features a nonstick surface for hassle-free cookie removal.
You can also buy it at Walmart – Target
Related: Best flan pan to buy in 2023
How we tested?
After researching and compiling a list of best pans for macarons our analysts tested them out individually using our Macarons recipe. The baking sheets were then categorized on the basis of durability, quality, temperature tolerance, and nonstick coating. We also analyzed the safety-handling features and tested the toxicity of the material on a PFOA, BPA, and PTFE basis.
