How to Store Crumbl Cookies?

Different Flavors of Crumbl Cookies

"We independently review the products we recommend! When you buy through links on AHealthyBowl.com, We may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more"

You can store the Crumbl Cookies at room temperature. However, it is recommended to consume them in 48-72 hours, because storing them at room temperature won’t keep them fresh for a long time, and the cookies will turn stale in 2 to 3 days.

You can increase the shelf life of Crumbl Cookies by up to 5 days by storing them in the refrigerator. Remember that the taste and texture will reduce to some extent. And, if the cookies are kept for more than 5 days, their freshness and texture will be lost.

Let’s look at the methods on how long Crumbl cookies can sit out.

What Is Special About Crumbl Cookies?

Jason McGowan‘s Crumbl cookies company is doing its best to release unique Cumbl cookie flavors every week. The secret between Crumbl cookies being so famous is their consistency in maintaining the quality of their cookies. The best part is that the company releases some of the finest and secret flavors every week. before we proceed further, make sure you check these copycat Crumbl cookie recipes you can make at home. Let’s see other factors that make them so special!

Crumbl Cookies Flavors

Do Crumbl cookies need to be refrigerated?

Crumbl Cookies typically don’t need to be refrigerated for short-term consumption. They are best enjoyed at room temperature due to their soft and chewy texture. However, if you plan to store them for an extended period or want to keep them fresh for several days, refrigeration can help preserve their quality.

Problems in Storing Crumbl Cookies

You cannot store Crumbl cookies in the traditional way of piling them up in an air-tight container altogether. This piling up will destroy the true essence of these delicious cookies.

Some of the problems in the way of storing Crumbl cookies are;

Decoration

Some crumbl cookies are in the shape of traditional cookies, while some are decorated in cupcake shapes. For example, a fried ice cream cookie has chocolate buttercream frosting; a cotton candy cookie has cheese frosting on top.

You cannot store all these cookies in the same bag or freeze them. If you don’t want to ruin the decorations and want to keep them as fresh as they were when you bought them, you’ll need to store them properly.

No Chemical Preservatives

Another issue you deal with while storing these cookies is care, because they are made fresh out of the oven. Their ingredients are entirely organic without any synthetic touch. These crumbl cookies do not involve any chemical preservatives or stabilizers.

That is why you need to preserve their flavor and keep them in an air-tight container. The Crumbl cookies have a shorter life span than the traditional ones available in the market.

Method 1: How To Store Crumbl Cookies at Room Temperature?

Before you proceed further, here is proof from the Crumbl cookies Official page which says that their cookies can be stored and kept frozen.

How To Store Crumbl Cookies

It is advisable not to keep your cookies at room temperature for more than 2 days; after that, they will go bad. After 3 days, they will change flavor and texture. You can quickly put them in the freezer to keep them edible for 5 days. Although they will taste entirely different after 5 days, they are still edible.

Here are step-by-step instructions to store Crumbl cookies

Step 1:  Select A Storage Container or Bag

You can choose any air-tight container or even a zip-lock bag will work fine in storing crumbl cookies. Whatever box or bag you choose, make sure that these containers are not pre-installed with any flavor, grease, or anything that crumbl cookies can absorb.

Some containers are best for storing Crmbl cookies, such as a glass jar with a wooden lid that can store these cookies and keep them fresh and crunchy for a more extended period.

Step 2: Add Cookies to the Containers

There are two ways to add your cookies to the container. If you have plain, traditionally shaped cookies, you can easily stack them up in the container. In this way, you will be able to save some space, and the shape of the cookie will remain the same.

If your cookies look like cupcakes or have a special frosting on their top, stacking them up will ruin their decoration. For frosted cookies, gently place them in the container or bag in a single layer without stacking them one after the other to preserve their shape and frosting.

Step 3: Keep Your Crumbl Cookies in A Dry and Cool Area

Store Crumbl cookies in a dry place; humid or wet places will make the cookies stale. In short, keep the container away from light and wet surfaces to protect them from ruining faster than expected.

Method 2: How to Store Crumbl Cookies in a Refrigerator?

If you want to store Crumbl cookies in a refrigerator, you can put them to preserve their frosting.

Put the cookies inside the fridge if room temperature is high, and the frosting can separate from the cake. But it is not only for frosted cooking; if regular cookies are out in hot temperatures, they will become stale faster than in cooler temperatures. You can keep the cookies inside the refrigerator for not more than 7 days. Remember that the cookies inside the fridge for this period will change flavor and texture.

Store Crumbl Cookies in a freezer
  1. Choose Your Container: Choose an air-tight container, not a Ziploc bag, to keep the cookies inside a refrigerator.
  2. Add Cookies Inside the Container: You can stack them in double or triple layers if there is space in the container. However, if the cookies are frosted, you will have to keep these cookies in a single layer.
  3. Place Crumbl Cookies in the refrigerator: Close the container and keep your cookies inside the fridge, try to keep them away from uncooked or cooked meat or any raw, aromatic vegetable because these cookies absorb the flavors and moisture, and their flavor and taste will change.

Method 3: How to Store Crumbl Cookies in the Freezer

freezing Crumbl Cookie in zip lock

Crumbl cookies can stay in the freezer for more than 6 months.

  • Freeze the Cookies One by One: Each plain or frosted cookie needs to be frozen separately inside the freezer by keeping it in a Ziploc bag or simply wrapping it with saran or another wrap after freezing separately for 1 to an hour.
  • Place Your Cookies Inside the Container: Take out the cookies from the freezer and add them to a large container; you can stack them or keep them on their sides without damaging the frosting as they are frozen. Close the container after stacking them, and then layer an aluminum foil around the container to add an extra protective layer around the container. You can store the container for more than 6 months. However, for better quality and flavor of Cumbl cookies, it is advisable to eat them within 1 month.
  • Place container in the freezer: Place the container inside the freezer and try not to overload it with extra stuff to prevent squishing the cookies.

Tips for Storing Crumbl Cookies

  1. Try to eat Crumbl cookies the same day because they taste fresh if eaten time.
  2. If you have some extra Cookies and can’t eat them the same day, try to keep them in an air-tight container; this will keep them fresh for a long time.
  3. Avoid keeping your cookies inside the fridge; cooling them down will make them dry and take away their soft and warm touch.
  4. If you decide to freeze them, always cover them in foil to prevent them from drying, and don’t put them near any smelling food that will change their odor completely.
  5. Keep your cookies away from the air as much as possible; air will dry them quickly.

Frequently Asked Questions

How to Revive Stale Crumbl Cookies?

The best way to revive an old crumbl cookie is to bake it; this will make the cookie dough soft and add sugar to it to make it sweeter. Bake the cookies for 10 to 15 minutes in a preheated oven and set the temperature at 180 degrees Celsius. Let it cool before eating.

What To Do with Leftover Crumbl Cookies?

If you have leftover cookies at the end of the day and don’t want to put them in the fridge or freezer to preserve their taste, you can serve them to your guests with coffee or tea. You can also put cookies in a bowl with ice cream; this combination tastes divine.
If you are making a pie or a cheesecake, you can add Crumbl Cookies as a crust. Crumbl cookies taste delicious if you grind them to use as a breading for fish or chicken. Make a Crumbl cookie milkshake or add it to your morning oatmeal or cereal.

Can You Leave Crumbl Cookies Out Overnight?

Crumbl cookie storage is possible overnight; leaving your crumbl cookies at room temperature is possible but keep them in an air-tight container. These crumbl cookies can stay at room temperature for 3 to 5 days as fresh as new.
If you want to store them after 5 days, you will need to put them in the fridge for 7 days and then in the freezer, where you can store them for more than 3 months. Keeping them for more than 1 month is not a good idea.

How Long Do Crumbl Cookies Last?

If you have a query about how long crumbl cookies are suitable, can you freeze crumbl cookies or not? Their lifetime entirely depends upon the location where you put them. If you keep them at room temperature, they will be fresh for 3 to 5 days, depending on the cookies’ ingredients and climate. In the fridge, they will last for 7 days; in the freezer, they can stay for 3 to 4 months, but that will change their texture and taste.

Hello!! My name is Adalynn I love to eat, travel, and eat some more! I am married to the man of my dreams and have a beautiful little girl whose smiles can brighten anyone’s day!